Spelling Tutorial: Apostrophe S In Names

A few weeks ago, I got an email from a woman, let's call her Mabel, asking about the use of possessive apostrophe S after names that end with S. Mabel's friend just had a sign made up for their house, which is for sale. Mabel's neighbours' surname is Ross. They wrote their sign as 'the Ross's house'. Mabel thinks that it should be 'the Ross' house'. Which form is right, and which is wrong? This is one of those grey areas in punctuation, actually. Both options (Ross' and Ross's) can be used!

Tip: If you're looking for good spelling tutorials, Troy and I highly recommend the popular spelling software, Ultimate Spelling.* Click Ultimate Spelling for details. The spelling tutorials are guaranteed to improve your spelling and solve your spelling problem with a full money-back guarantee.


One of my (older) English reference books says use whichever one you prefer, and whatever reads better (I would prefer Ross').

However, the Cambridge Guide to Australian English Usage says that the possessive form of proper nouns ending in -s has led to "great diversity of opinion and a variety of practices" (ie a lot of disagreements!).

The early convention was to exempt all proper nouns ending with S from the usual rule (add apostrophe S), and just add the apostrophe, and no S (hence Ross', Jones', Jesus', Xerxes', or Menzies'). Now it seems that the following variations are in use:

Rule 1) Usual rule applies (ie add apostrophe S at the end), but not for literary, classical, or religious names (Ross's, Jones's, Menzies's, Dickens', Jesus', Xerxes'). In this example, Ross and Jones and Menzies don't fall into the category of 'literary, classical, or religious names', so they get the 'apostrophe S' treatment, but the other names don't.

Rule 2) Usual rule applies, but not for names of two or more syllables (Ross's, Jones's, Menzies', Dickens', Jesus', Xerxes'). In this example, Ross and Jones are short names, one syllable long, so they get the apostrophe without the S, but the other names, which are all longer, get the apostrophe with the S.

Rule 3) Usual rule applies, but not for names whose last syllable sounds like 'eez' (Ross's, Jones's, Dickens's, Menzies', Jesus's, Xerxes'). In this example, the only names who end with the 'eez' sound are Menzies and Xerxes. The other names don't end with this sound, so they get the apostrophe S.

Rule 4) Exempt names whose possessive form is pronounced with the same number of syllables as the plain form. The application of this rule depends on personal pronunciation of the name.

The easiest way to get conformity in this complicated system of arbitrary 'rules' is to just apply the apostrophe S in all cases across the board (which is what the Australian and USA government style manuals currently recommend) — with some exceptions for literary, classical, or religious works, occasionally, where the older tradition of just using the apostrophe, and no S, is more usual.


*Troy and I recommend only products that we have tried and tested. These include Ultimate Spelling. We have agreed to receive a commission from some sales of Ultimate Spelling because we are happy to endorse that spelling software.

 

Last modified on Saturday, 28 November 2015 00:04
You are here: Spell Better Spelling Tutorial: Apostrophe S In Names
BLOG COMMENTS POWERED BY DISQUS